I have a STV-3. The neck is a little slender and thin for me, but its such a nice guitar that I can deal with it. Others that I have tried (not owned) are, Bacchus, 70's strat, fender custom shop, and fender vintage reissue. I have not tried a Navigator. One thing I really like about the Van Zandt is the finish and construction of the guitar. Finish is super thin, frets are dressed perfectly and the guitar just feels extremely well built. On top of that, the Van zandts sound really good to me. Side by side, it makes a fender USA standard feel like a toy guitar. What is the finish like on the Navigator. I have considered one of those to, but it is nearly impossible to find one to try out in my area. I would have to try it before spending that kind of money. The specs on the STV-1s are a little confusing to me. The website says neck width is 41.5 at the nut, but when I have inquired about used guitars shops have told me the width is 45.